Carl Kaminsky is like one of those guys with a metal detector on the beach; except he has no metal detector, no straw hat, isn’t wearing shorts and is on a city street. OK, not so similar — but he is keeping his eyes down looking for anything of interest.
On a grate, he picks up a soaking wet newspaper for reasons I can’t imagine. Then he spots a wallet and picks it up. He spends about the same amount of time looking for owner as OJ did looking for the real killers — then pockets the wallet.
He goes home to a very humble apartment and his wife Anna (Jo Van Fleet). Fleet was last seen as a thoroughly repulsive shrew in Dangerous People. Here, she is not as insane, but despite being abused by her brutish husband, she is no more likable or empathetic a character.
Carl is in, what apparently for him, is a good mood even though he is still cruel to Anna. And he’s not mentioning the wallet to her. She asks what he is so happy about, he tells her to “shut up with the questions.” Christ, what is this guy like on a bad day?
Finally he does whip out the wallet and shows her that it contains 52 $100 bills, and there is no name in the wallet. Anna’s plan is to return the wallet in anticipation of a big reward. Carl has a slightly different plan.
The next day, Anna sees an ad in the paper offering a generous reward for the wallet. Anna wants to call, but Carl says he will return the wallet to the owner. He comes home furious, telling Anna that there was no reward. He then heads up to the attic to hide the wallet.
Two weeks later, Anna is still pissed about being stiffed on the reward. She sees that the ad is still running in the paper, then she is really pissed and catches Carl counting the Bejamins in the attic.
Soon, Anna is buying new furniture, a new dress, and a mink coat. When Carl demands that she return it, she threatens to call the owner of the wallet. After a screaming match where Anna smacks Carl and dares her to hit her back, he retreats to the attic.
She brings him a poisoned cup of coffee while he is counting the money yet again. He clubs her to death with a statuette, then drinks the coffee.
- AHP Deathwatch: No survivors among those with data on IMDb.