I’ll say this for The Miracle of Alice Ames, at least it wasn’t painful just to watch. Why Are You Here? is the most visually offensive episode since New Year’s Day.
A limo rolls up in front of a club and an unctuous windbag pops his head out of the sun-roof. He is “Jerry Rulack, Duke of the Night” on the TV show Night Sight. I give the episode credit for its prescience in predicting the future of TV. Not so much for predicting reality shows like The Kardashians, but for predicting how shitty TV in general would be. The show being filmed in this episode is like every DJ portrayed on TV — they would draw an audience of close to zero.
Jerry gets out of the limo and leads us to “. . . clubs like this. Currently the hottest or coolest club in town.” He promises to take us in and ask the question which is apparently the beloved catch-phrase of the series which is sweeping the nation: “Why are you here?”
We follow him through the crowd in the club. A mixture of punks, dandies, flashing lights and coke-heads. Nothing wipes that game-show host smile off his face, though. And the finger-snapping — what the hell is all that finger-snapping for? He approaches a woman at the bar who is dressed like the widow at a Corleone funeral and asks her name. She is the only character I don’t hate so far as she screams “F*** off!” in his smirking face. Then he springs his A-material, “Why are you here?” and she just scream-screams in his face. And he never missed a snap with those fingers.
He travels through the club filming more weirdos, punks, coke-snorters, and — the horror! — two gay guys. The blaring music, flashing lights, frequent camera edits and finger-snapping go on and on and on. He sees a couple making out and asks his idiotic signature question, “Why are you here?” The woman shows her boobs and the episode even manages to make that boring.
Jerry interviews some dandy in the coke-room. He appears to be wearing a blazer over a wife-beater which shows way too much chest hair. Was there ever a time when this would have been cool? He also appears to be using a make-up pencil to accentuate his butt-chin. He leads Jerry and his crew up to a private area to see “the most beautiful, sweetest, sought after, fought over, richest girl” in town.
The girl turns out to be Helen Hunt up in the VIP room surrounded by hanger-ons. Jerry asks his usual insipid question, “Why are you here?” She says, “Nowhere else to go,” and he gives her insipid answer a big raspberry, thumbs-down and childish face. Honestly, who would watch this shit? And who would watch this shit?
With the exception of Jerry’s barely-seen crew, every character in this episode is repulsive. I had hopes that Helen Hunt might elevate the material, but was disappointed. She has always seemed like a nice person, but she is just grossly miscast in this role. Maybe her relatability was supposed to be a counterpoint to her bum-exploitation [1] and crack-smoking [2], but it really just made me want to watch Twister again. Unfortunately Brad Davis, who is on screen nearly every second, is dreadful.
There actually was something here that could have been salvaged. It was a target-rich environment for satire — the club scene, reality TV, divas — but nothing lands.
Garbage.
Post-Post:
- [1] In the homeless meaning, not anal.
- [2] In the drug meaning, not anal.
- Rated 3rd worst episode of the series in IMDb’s increasingly credible ratings.
- Also from this director: The Legendary Billy B. Despite being born in New Zealand and working down-under during the 1980’s, even Ray Bradbury Theater knew better than to hire him.
The episode begins with a bit of German Expressionism; and I believe that expression is ausgezeichnet! [1] It was an unexpected bit of black & white artistry in a frequently dreary series with rain, fog, shadows, odd angles, Kafkaesque police, and big-ass clocks just scary in their size and starkness. I guess a whole episode in this style would have been too much, but what an awesome opening! Alas, it was just a Traum.
Denise gets away from Ron and runs downstairs. Wanting to help the family, Jimmy points the gun at Ron. That goes about as you expect — Ron takes the gun from him and murders the entire family. Again, this is awesomely — sorry — executed.

Summers tells her, “Billy B. was one of the original acid rockers, the greatest American guitarist pre-Hendrix, the big rock sex god after Elvis and before Jim Morrison.” Unlike the other three dumb-asses, his death was not self-inflicted by drugs — he was shot on stage 20 years ago. And unlike two of those three, he seems to be alive.
Summers busts him for giving the exact same inane response he gave a reporter 20 years earlier. His other dopey answers are also rehashes of old interviews. They want some new material, so Summers challenges Billy B. to play more than a simple riff. When he seems unable, they peg him as a phony. He pulls a gun on them. Summers proves to be quite agile as he leaps through a glass window, then jumps from the 2nd story. Sadly he is killed by Red or Sonny or whatever Billy B.’s lackey is named.
Gary Busey.
requests What a Friend We Have in
ressed neatly in a nice mid-western style. The Armani-clad reporter comes in just in time to hear Powers wonder if maybe “Jesus has already returned and was flushed down an abortionist’s toilet.” Gotta say if that’s your philosophy, it is a pretty good question.

The next morning, still wearing the same double-breasted suit — that’s reason enough to break up with a dude right there — Shephard goes in search of Ellie. He goes to her hair salon and starts flipping up hair dryers in search of her. He is man-handled, tossed out and given such a slap by the fabulous owner [1] of the salon. That’s not a story I’d tell down at the VFW Hall. The dog witnesses the whole scene.
Carl comes home from New York to find his home has been wrecked. I still can’t figure out what the point of this is. Carl is understandably peeved, but Shephard tells him not to be angry. Just to be safe, the dog kills him.
I was highly critical of Michael O’Keefe’s (Shepard) performance for most of the episode. He was never much of an actor, but here he just seemed all over the board. The revelation that he was nuts helped explain away some of that; many of his mannerisms are meant to imitate a dog. The basics of the story were great. I just wish I understood the sex doll, the sofa fort, the destruction of Carl’s house, and the symbolism of wearing the same suit day after day. I guess the destruction is what you would expect from a dog. Maybe the suit was like the dog’s fur — he can’t change it.