Alfred Hitchcock straight-up murders a dude in the prologue. So that’s new.
Captain Fisher is recalling one of the cases of his early career. Milton Potter, the “tamest criminal” Fisher ever saw, was just paroled after doing 12 years for embezzlement. He says, “Milton Potter had worked for Metro Investments since he got out of college — a total of 13 years.” Since Potter is played by 56 year old Paul Hartman, it is safe to say he was not Dean’s List material. [1] Fisher says he was making only $60/week and describes him as a quiet, friendless drone.
Milton does not show for work one day 12 years ago, and no one notices. The second day, however, they notice because $200,000 is missing. [3] Young Lt. Fisher is assigned to the case. No one can describe anything about Potter, not even his eye color after 13 years. He did seem to read a lot of travel magazines, though.
The next day Potter goes to the police station and gives himself up. However he will not return the cash. He goes to jail, does his time offscreen, and is paroled 12 years later. Fisher — now the Captain — goes to see Potter. He wants to remind him that even though he did the time, that doesn’t mean the money is his. So Potter returns the money. That paragraph took 13 minutes on the screen.
There is a nifty wrap-up that involves Potter finally getting to travel, and babes in high-heels playing shuffleboard.
Mostly, it was a lot of talking, though. That’s not necessarily a bad thing. Paul Hartman was believable as the mild-mannered, sad-sack Potter. Wendell Holmes was a hoot as his blowhard boss. The other performances were competent. Despite a fine twist, this was more of a character piece than we usually get from AHP.
Warning to anyone attempting to duplicate Potter’s scheme: Putting $200,000 in the bank for 12 years nowadays would leave you with about $200,005.

Potter is the guy on the left, but really, who cares?
Other Stuff:
- [1] Actually, the character is said to be 34 [2] at the time of the crime, thus 46 for half of the episode. F***ing actors, man!
- [2] So he graduated at 21 — a genius!
- [3] When another office drone comes in to report the embezzlement to company VP Halverson, he stutters. Halverson [4] demands, “What is it, Newton? Out with it — I don’t have all day!” I love the way old shows have the boss barking at employees and calling them by their last name. Did that really happen?
- [4] It bugs me when a show has a son with the same name as his father; or characters with similar names. It is just pointlessly confusing. Here, we have Halverson and Harv Ellison which, if you’ve had a few drinks, sound pretty similar.
- AHP Deathwatch: One survivor; although at 97, I wonder if IMDb missed a phone call.
- Title Analysis: Potter says he turned himself in because he is not the running type. Also not the running type: Alfred Hitchcock.
- This would have been a rare non-murder AHP if not for Hitchcock’s opening shot.
Mary McNeal is a regression therapist or, as they are more accurately known, a fraud. The exploration of past lives seems to be a real thing in this world, so I am happy to go along with it.
Mary returns to her office and finds another business operating there. OK, classic TZ, she has slipped into another world. Great, I always dig these stories; but when did she enter this world? Wouldn’t the logical point have been when she hypnotized herself? But that sure looked like her office that she woke up in — same blue walls and white sofa. But somehow the world changed after she left the office, and before she visited her patient. No matter.
She wakes up in a warehouse and is questioned by Sinclair and another man who I assume is the one credited as Vigilante on IMDb. Vigilante says it is “utterly unheard of” for a person not to remember their past lives. Wait, Sinclair said just a minute ago that “new souls” with no memories do exist. Anyhoo, Mary is even more suspect because she doesn’t even have a current life — there is no record of her existence. Vigilante menacingly tells her that means no one will miss her.
Harold Mason (Leslie Nielsen) wakes up sitting at the kitchen table where he fell asleep 1) playing cards, 2) reading the newspaper, 3) drinking coffee, or 4) tidying up. Well, we can rule out #4 because the table is a mess, strewn with newspapers, cards, coffee and Harold’s noggin.
He goes to see Borrow again. Borrow refuses to help him this time because the securities are non-negotiable. Harold presses the button on Borrow’s desk that opens the door to the time machine. So I guess that memory wipe procedure has not been perfected yet. Borrow refuses to divulge Harold’s previous life, only saying he has made the identical bonehead choices in both lives. On the plus side, he says this is the result with all his clients.
The episode begins in the fictional town of Killbrook, PA so as to not embarrass any any real Pennsylvanians; although the citizens of Millbrook, PA might be getting some calls. Two men go to Mrs. Peterson’s Boarding House near the Institute of Advanced Astrophysics. [1] The sign outside advertises “Board and Room” so maybe some reality-warping shenanigans have already taken place.
They melt the comb down and fabricate the part needed for the device. Brewster is unsure what calamity might occur when he turns it on, as it will release massive, never-before seen levels of energy. He asks Ruth if she would like to leave, but she gamely say she will stay. Then he tells her to turn the device on. Rrrrright, as long as you’re here. Brewster watches a couple of vacuum tubes light up and says “Dr. Pliny was right. We’ve just seen the end of the Atomic Age.”